General haig does not deserve the reputation of the butcher of the somme despite the enormous casualties at the somme, the british did go on to win the war, which was the main priority. The cartoon mocks the absence of general haig at the battle of the somme, even though it is a cartoon it does have some truth to it as in the way that general haig always stayed 50km behind the trenches to ensure he was as far away from the battle as possible but still able to give and receive orders. Free essays on does general haig deserve the title butcher of the somme search how far was the field marshall douglas haig responsible for the failings of the british armies on the western front in 1916 and 1917.
Does general haig deserve to be remembered as ‘the butcher of the somme’ on the 28th of july 1914 austria-hungary declared war on serbia as revenge for the assassination of archduke franz ferdinand and several other things, but the assassination was the trigger. Douglas haig was britain’s commander-in-chief during the somme battle and took much criticism for the sheer loss of life in this battle haig was born in 1861 in edinburgh he was commissioned in the cavalry in 1885 and served both in the campaigns in the sudan and in the boer war in south africa between 1899 and 1902. Did general haig deserve the title “butcher of the somme” general haig was a british commander, and senior officer of the british army, on the western front for world war i, including the battle of the somme which was fought from july to november in 1916.
The scale of the failure, under the overall command of field marshal sir john french and general sir douglas haig, was so huge it brought about a major re-think of the way the british army. General douglas haig was one of the commanders from the british army in the battle of somme, the battle with one of the highest casualties in british military history some people called him “butcher haig” or “butcher of the somme” after his death in 1928, because he sent thousands of british soldiers to their death. How far was general haig responsible for the failings of the british war effort on the western front 1916 – 1917 retention of title was the battle of the somme a failure. While field marshal haig and his staff lived a life of luxury in a chateau far behind the lines compare his insensitivity to the action of a truly great general, the duke of. It may be fashionable to knock haig, but from 9 august 1914 to 11 november 1918 he led what is arguably the most successful feat of arms in the history of the british army.
General haig was the general that led the attacks in the battle of somme after the war, he was bitterly criticized for underestimating the germans and people gave him the name butcher of somme. Did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme papers did general haig deserve to be the team and britain to victory and he is the hero of that general haig deserves the title the butcher of the butcher of the somme history essay – uk essays ukessays the issue of douglas haig x27s role as a general on the butcher of the somme. Haig wanted to break through to the northern coast of belgium from where german u-boats were targeting british ships he ordered soldiers to attack on july 31, 1917. Did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme 1 july 1916, battle of somme started, fought by the armies of the british and french empires against the german empire it took place on either side of the river somme in france, and it ended on 18 november 1916. The extra reading i did about haig and somme i can say that haig was not an “uncaring general”, but he hade some mistakes on his career i also blame the people around him who gave him wrong information and one of haig’s major mistakes was that he never visited the somme during the war.
General douglas haig was a british senior officer during world war i he commanded the british expeditionary force (bef) from 1915 to the end of the war he was commander during the battle of the somme, the battle with one of the highest casualties in british military history. This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the douglas haig, 1st earl haig article this is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject put new text under old text. How far does general haig deserve to be known as ‘the butcher of the somme’ the battle of the somme was the most costly battle in terms of casualties every in the history of british military. This powerpoint is designed to span two lessons and includes 6 activities to help students assess the tactics that general haig used at the battle of the somme in 1916. Arguably haig does deserve his nickname this is because haig sent thousands of men to their deaths continuously after his war efforts seemed not to be working for instance 60,000 soldiers died in the first day alone in the battle of the somme.
Major-general sir john davidson, one of haig's biographers, praised haig's leadership, and since the 1980s many historians have argued that the public hatred in which haig's name had come to be held failed to recognise the adoption of new tactics and technologies by forces under his command, the important role played by british forces in the. How far was general haig responsible for the failings of the british war effort on the western front 1916 – 1917 did all of lord kitchener’s volunteer army march to war with zest and idealism in the first place. General haig who was a new commander and in charge of the british army was the man who initially came up with the plan which consisted of innocent lives being lost, however he did not regret it, he thought it was a worthy sacrifice which led to the victory of britain.
Douglas haig was born in edinburgh on 19 june 1861 into a wealthy family who owned a whisky business he studied at oxford university and in 1884 went to the royal military academy at sandhurst. Does general haig deserve to be remembered 'the butcher of the somme' 1331 words 6 pages field marshall sir douglas haig (19 june 1861 – 29 january 1928) was a senior commander in the first world war (wwi), and perhaps one of the most notable figures in british military history. But haig’s attachment to the horse was abiding and stubborn, and he went so far as to argue that the machine gun was an overrated weapon—especially against the horse generals, the cynics like to say, are always fighting the last war. Published: tue, 06 jun 2017 the issue of douglas haig’s role as a general on the western front, during the battle of the somme in 1916, has been thoroughly questioned by many historians to date.
Haig had won, as he had said he could, but did he deserve any credit many writers - including those writing just after the war - have criticised haig for his tactics, for the great loss of men and, above all, for his defeat at the battle of the somme. Does general haig deserve to be remembered as ‘the butcher of the somme’notes for teachers / candidatesyour assignment should start with an introductionhere you should briefly outline the history of the battle of the sommeyou should also refer to the different ways that people have interpreted haig’ rolein the battle of the sommethis.